Sunday, July 10, 2011

Tell It Like It Is

Every so often while rolling, there is a moment where a teammate utters a sound so booming that it draws the attention of everyone else on the mat. Typically this sound has a sense of urgency, pain, anger, or some combination.

On one particular occasion that I experienced this, a female voice uttered a very stern, loud, "TAP!" Sitting on the sidelines, I was in a position to hear what came next. In no uncertain terms, the high-level female began reprimanding an overzealous, male white belt. The lecture was audible to those not rolling. And if it wasn't audible, the tension was certainly obvious. It garnered smirks from other upper-belts who were on the sidelines. The message of the rebuke was clear and concise. So white belt buddy was given a lesson in front of everyone.

And I thought it was flipping awesome.

I thought to myself, "Heck yes. This woman takes ownership of her safety and quality of training. She tells it like it is and doesn't avoid the issue. She does not care what anyone else thinks. So. Awesome."

I had seen this white belt guy rolling with people before; he looked scary. His overzealousness was not a one time deal. When fate had it that we were to roll together a few classes later, a male purple belt gave me a knowing look. I honestly think he was worried for my safety.

But this was post-lecture.

I was still hesitant in being offensive for fear of retribution, but white belt buddy was chill. I was relieved. I don't actually have any proof, but I think it's possible that the words of the upper-belt changed the way he approaches his training partners. Well, the female white belt ones, anyway.

The essence of this story is something that I struggle with and that I think might be lacking in some BJJ clubs or individuals: communication.

I don't mean the easy communication, that which involves technique details or advice. But the communication that is more reflective of emotions.

While the mats are our escape, they make for interesting politics what with all the different backgrounds, experience levels, genders, goals, expectations, and personalities. It's complicated! Deciding how to approach rolling with someone can be complicated, never mind talking to them.

There are five key reasons that I struggle with communication on the mat.
  1. I have anxiety of not wanting to "be a girl". This is definitely the biggest issue for me. I don't want to be perceived as a wimp or a baby. I don't want to tell someone that they need to chill because I don't want to compromise my training. I don't want to alienate training partners. I don't want them to let me get away with stupid things for fear of getting me "worked up". I don't want to be perceived differently than their male training partners.
  2. I am not very diplomatic. Off the mat, I often tell it like it is -- in a way that is not taken very well. I guess I'm saying that I can be a jerk sometimes. This is something I am working on. On the mat, I tend not to say anything because it's not immediately obvious to me how to make it positive.
  3. I don't want to hurt people's feelings. I don't want to make people feel badly about themselves. No matter how tactful you are, the truth can still hurt.
  4. Communication is a two-way street. You can talk all you want, but the other person needs to be willing to listen and act upon what you say. This part may be the trickiest of them all. You may not believe in one-way streets but they still exist. (Does anyone other than John get my 30 Rock references?)
  5. I am a white belt. I perceive that this fact makes anything I say mean less and makes others less willing to listen. I, myself, admit to feeling this way when words are coming from a white belt whose skills I don't respect that much. (For example, a white belt who is six classes in giving me "advice". Yes, I struggle with my ego sometimes.)
It is important to me to become a better communicator on the mat for two main reasons. It is my safety, not anyone else's. Recently I was rolling with a male white belt for the first time. It was the sort of roll where almost immediately after clapping hands you are on edge and prepared for crazy. I am not fond of these rolls because I like it when all my limbs are working. I also don't have self-defense goals, so I really just prefer relaxed people.

Due to some frantic actions on his part, as I was passing, I got hit in the side of the head somehow. Immediately, both my ears started ringing and I couldn't hear properly. It was as though I had water clogging my ears and a very lame orchestra surrounding me. I kept rolling and shortly after he gave up as I was starting to attack his arm from side. (FYI, the ringing stopped that same night, and after a few days, I could hear normally again.)

Afterwards, I said nothing to him about what happened. About how he could stand to relax. About how he should be cognizant of his partners' safety. I regret this and it is part of the reason why I started thinking about this whole communication thing.

Who cares if I am a white belt and maybe he doesn't want to listen to me? Frankly, the encounter made me not want to roll with him again. It would be nice if that were not the case. Avoidance isn't useful here. It doesn't fix anything and doesn't improve my jiu jitsu. (I find that rolling with new, spazzy people shows me how much I have improved, but little else.) If I roll with him again and I get hurt in some way, whose fault is it? His or mine?

Thus, open communication makes for better learning. I recently watched the Globetrotter's five-month old video on how to slowroll, or flow roll, as I like to call it. What really stood out to me is that one of the rules of flow rolling is "communicate with your partner".

I think it is fantastic that it is being explicitly encouraged. I have never really experienced that at clubs, but there have definitely been times that I left a roll wishing that it felt appropriate to say something instead of leaving frustrated, confused, irritated, or a little frightened for my safety. Verbal communication in life is important -- with a significant other, friends, family, strangers, colleagues, classmates, customer service employees, during partner yoga, etc. So why not make use of those skills on the mat?

Part of the challenge is that, on the mat, some of the communication is non-verbal. If you act like a spazz, that experienced blue belt is going to really demonstrate to you just how good his technique is and make everything you do futile. This is often done in a sort of patriarchal, king-of-the-jungle way.

This approach does not really work for me. I can't get the message across in the same way. Sure, I can now outsmart and control some of the "livelier" opponents by staying relaxed and using jiu jitsu. But it certainly is not the same. And really, I would rather not have to.

So from now on I'm going to try to be diplomatic yet honest with my training partners when appropriate. (Just as I would like them to be honest with me.) I hope that having the guts to practice open communication in an intelligent way enables me to learn in a productive, safe, and positive environment -- an environment that I am, in part, helping to foster.

11 comments:

  1. This...is a phenomenal post. You hit on one of the core issues in communication on the mats.

    "Part of the challenge is that, on the mat, some of the communication is non-verbal. If you act like a spazz, that experienced blue belt is going to really demonstrate to you just how good his technique is and make everything you do futile. This is often done in a sort of patriarchal, king-of-the-jungle way."

    That right there is the communication currency of men. More than once, I've had issues with guys and the immediate response from higher belts was "you need me to take care of him?" Not to blame anyone, but this seems to be how men communicate. Instead of correcting behavior verbally, they establish boundaries to curtail bad behavior.

    I give serious credit to your female higher belt. I hope to get there one day. Not sure I have the confidence yet to react at that level.

    For now, when it's a direct problem, I calm myself and tell spazzy lower belts to breathe or remind them to go slow on submissions since you don't want to ruin somebody's elbow, which usually calms them down.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ash, are you reading my mind? I've been thinking about this lately too. And I am a 'higher' belt and I don't have the guts of the lady you watched.

    I have some of the same reasons you do for having difficulties speaking up. Number 1, not wanting to be seen as 'a girl/wimp' is a big one for me. Number 3, not wanting to hurt feelings also stops me from speaking up.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Let me know if you come up with a tactful way to communicate to someone (especially a new person) that they are a spazz on the mat. Sadly, we all have those moments. There will always be someone better... and then there are those with massive ego's who will never be a polite training partner. I get frustrated with training for the very reason that I don't really care about rolling to win.. I just want to train PERIOD.. I actually hate that (for the most part) the people I have trained with are stiff, tight and rigid. Quite frankly I do not care if I ever get another belt or promotion for the rest of the days I train, in fact I gave the last belt I earned back. Some people need a belt to gauge their progress, some people (like me) do not need or want that as a motivator, I don't care.. I train because I love it not for the status of a belt.. Funny, though when discussing "communication" a person is referred by their belt level and the "higher" belt level seems to get a little more respect however they can be spazzy too, though the higher belt level ought to know better..
    My question is where is the line drawn between offering training advice to the new spazzy person and just complaining about the inconvenience having to train with them after gaining some experience .. We've ALL started as the new spazz.. My advice is be careful because the people above you may be thinking the same thing..

    I say it is not cool to "lecture" a student or training partner in front of anyone.. ever! Be respectful take them aside and politely ask them to ease up, or whatever you need to say.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @ Megan: Thanks for your comment. It is how some guys seem to communicate. It's not better or worse than saying something aloud, but it simply doesn't work for me so I am seeking an alternative. Excellent advice on how to start dealing with it currently. I think most people would be receptive to a friendly reminder like that. No one wants to actually hurt their training partners, no matter how new they are.

    @ Laura: Yes, I have been reading your mind.

    @ Anon: Thanks for chiming in! I guess where the communication gets tactful is that you don't call them spazzy.... You would say positive things, like Megan suggests above.

    I'm not sure why you're talking about promotions in that way....I guess I was sending something across that I didn't really mean regarding my belt level. However, I think it is unavoidable that people with more experience (typically denoted by belts and stripes) are going to be respected more. You are absolutely right that there are upper-belts who are spazzy. I intend to try to communicate with them too. You are also right, they should definitely know better! This makes them even harder to talk to, if you ask me. Maybe it is an ego thing, or maybe it's just because no one has had the guts to tell them that they are being too hard?

    I know that this sort of good communication is possible because Georgette has been on the receiving end of some diplomatic suggestions. She responded to it quite positively. And if she didn't blog so darn much I would be able to find it a lot easier and provide a link! :)

    For the record, I was not a spazz. I knew about spazzy beginners and I was adamant that I would not be one, so I would not move unless I knew "what I was supposed to do". This lead to uber passivity which was a problem in its own right. Who wants to train with the person who does nothing?

    This idea of communication is not about disrespecting people by "lecturing" them, making them feel awkward, or feel inferior to more experienced people. (Hence me explicitly trying not to be a jerk.) It is about taking ownership over my safety and my training. Truly, the realization in that moment was not that I should start "lecturing" people, but that it is actually okay for me to say something.

    You're right, though. It is not terribly cool to "lecture" a training partner, and it was definitely an emotional moment. But I also don't think it's cool to put your training partner in danger because of your actions that are preventable or at least changeable if someone is willing to point them out to you.

    Sometimes, safety in a club is not emphasized enough for me to feel comfortable, or the "boundaries" as Megan mentions are established non-verbally. Liam, over on Allie's post about teaching beginners, listed clarifying the importance of safety as his number one item for beginners. I don't think there is anything wrong with me doing this myself if I don't feel like I'm in an environment that is as safe as I would like?

    You have to understand that I may be in a situation where I feel that if I don't start saying things to people, I may get hurt and won't be able to train -- because, like you, I also just want to train! I have had far too many extended breaks from bjj due to injury (NONE due to spazzes) that I would not be able to forgive myself if some accident happened because someone was too overzealous and I was too afraid to "be a girl" and say something constructive to them.

    At the same time, I know accidents happen even with the best of intentions. I know that not everyone is going to actively respond to feedback. I know that I am going to choose my "battles". I know I am going to speak with patience, understanding, respect, and a smile. =)

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Anon again: Wow! Awesome and thanks! Apparently your comment evoked a post within a post!
    POSTCEPTION.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I wonder where the coach is when all this "lecturing" is happening. Isn't it his/her job to make sure you get a safe training partner?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I resemble the spazzy white belt model above. I don't intend to hurt my partners and try to be gentle. It may be that some of us need to take a more honest look at whether we have the mental and physical ability to ever get our heads around the sport. Just as some people are tone deaf and will never sing, I am beginning to think that there are some of us who are BJJ-challenged and will never outgrow the spazz stage. Until we figure it out, or move on to a more compatible sport or hobby, it may be that there are some of us that should just be avoided at all costs.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for writing this inspiring post. Good, clear, and concise communication is important in all areas of life.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @ Triin: Yes, there is a lot of truth in that. Even if coaches don't strictly match partners, I think they should be sharing the safety message. In my experience there is a huge amount of variation in clubs in terms of supervision of partners. It's interesting, though. Partner matching would be a very unique challenge, especially since I think people can roll differently depending on the person.

    Overall, I do think it's important for the coach to have a role in safety -- and communication with your coaches about it is important, too -- but I think it's only fair for me (or us?) to take some responsibility. I am 26 after all!

    @ John: hahahah! You may be right. But, I'm not convinced that you are that person, merely for the fact that you obviously have awareness. Perhaps you can roll with explicit goals that allow for you to relax, depending on the issue. For example, let your partner work and only worry about defense. Or, if you want to be offensive, make subs catch-and-release.

    @ Jodi: Thanks for the comment! It's definitely something that we can always be working on.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Your writing is very gripping. This is a fantastic blog Ashley!

    I don't think there is a lack of communicaton within Jiu Jitsu though, I think there is a lack of communication in the world. Jiu Jitsu is so amazing because it puts us face to face (and sometime face to ass) with other people in a way where you HAVE to communicate. People who learn to do that, draw great benefits from this awesome art on and off the mat.

    After all, what is the point of becoming a fluid guard player with excellent sweeps that have great timing if you can't listen communicate with your kids with the same fluidity and awareness?

    Once again, very impressive writing Ashley.

    ReplyDelete
  11. @ Liam: Thanks for commenting! You have a point -- jiu jitsu does tend to bring out our personal strengths and weaknesses. In terms of communication, and what I'm going to call confrontation, avoidance is something I've been working to remedy. Though, I'm not sure that the dynamics with our training partners is the same as the dynamics we would have with our children. Maybe next time I'm uncomfortable in a situation with a training partner for whatever reason, I'll just say, "Billy! Don't put that in your mouth!!" and see how they react. hahahah!

    You, sir, are an excellent communicator. I *definitely* need to take a lesson from you. You presented your contrary position in a compliment sandwich, which left me feeling good about myself, not at all defensive, and completely open to considering your position. I really need to work on this form of sandwich-making.

    ReplyDelete